Atlantic City
Cherry Hill
East Windsor
Franklin Park
Jersey City
North Brunswick
Oak Tree Rd
South Plainfield

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill (NJ)

Salt 'n' Pepper
1888 RT 70 East
Cherry Hill, NJ 08003

Other New Jersey Indian Restaurants
Salt n Pepper Indian Cuisine

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill: Spiceless Disappointment

Indian food without the right heat and spices is like Pamela Anderson or good ol' Dolly Parton without those magnificent, jiggling tatas.

A recent visit to Salt 'n' Pepper on Rt 70 East in Cherry Hill during lunch turned out to be a merciless assault on my spice and heat craving Indian tastebuds.

Imagine a manchester on Dolly or Pamela and you'll understand how I felt during my meal.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Upma Bhajia Image ©
Upma, Onion Pakora

Whether it is the South Indian delicacy Upma or North Indian curries like Mutter Paneer, Bhindi Masala or Channa Peshawari, the story was the same. They were all badly lacking in the heat and spice that gives Indian food its deserved reputation as one of the great cuisines of the world.

Lamb Biryani, a great favorite of mine, had so little heat that I wondered if any chillies had gone into its preparation.

I quickly understood the crux of the problem at Salt 'n' Pepper. Like countless other Indian restaurants in the U.S., Salt 'n' Pepper too has toned down the heat and spices in the food believing that Americans will find it hard to take the heat.

It's a familiar but depressing story.

Most Indian restaurants are not cooking for Indians who can take the heat but for the Americans whose lament is Take the Heat Off Me, Baby. :)

Upma, Onion Pakora

Upma was so low on salt making me wonder whether Salt 'n' Pepper ran out of it.

To add insult to injury, the texture of Upma was so pasty that it felt like I was eating boiled flour rather than the popular South Indian tiffin item.

Upma was also badly missing on ginger and green chilli, items that provide the yummy flavor to this dish.

Now any restaurant that serves soft, rubbery Onion Bhajia or Pakora is revealing its contempt for diners.

Pakoras are a crispy delightful appetizer. And to place soft, rubbery ones before paying customer is a felony in my dictionary.

Lamb Biryani and Chicken

One spoon of the Lamb Biryani in my mouth and tears rolled down my cheeks.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Lamb Biryani Image ©
Lamb Biryani

I swear.

Lamb Biryani is a blessing bestowed upon South Asians when God was in his most benevolent mood.

And to play mischief with one of God's most wondrous creations is the most venal sin.

Sure the Lamb Biryani was prepared with Basmati rice and included lamb pieces.

But it failed at a fundamental level - spiciness. Biryani whether Lamb or Chicken is a spicy, aromatic rice dish prepared with Bay Leaves, Cloves, Cardamom, Marati Mogga, Cinnamon, Ginger, Mint Leaves, Garlic and other spices.

But Salt 'n' Pepper's Lamb Biryani was so low on the Biryani spices and packed only a faint flavor.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Tandoori Chicken Image ©
Tandoori Chicken

If any spices had gone into Lamb Biryani, it must be only in the imagination of the cook.

Although it did not have the smoky flavor that Tandoori Chicken usually has in North Indian restaurants, it was one of the better meat items of my meal.

With a marinated layer of masala paste, it was the only item that made me seek a second helping.

Should I return to Salt 'n' Pepper, it'll be for the Tandoori Chicken.

Butter Chicken was another pothole I fell into.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Butter Chicken Image ©
Butter Chicken

Although the Butter Chicken was on the creamy side, there was little flavor in the gravy.

In fairness to Salt 'n' Pepper, few Indian restaurants in NJ/NY seem to get Butter Chicken right.

Wonder why??

Vegetable Entrees

As I wandered over to graze on the vegetarian side, I discovered the non-discriminatory nature of Salt 'n' Pepper's kitchen.

They are equally opportunity offenders and do not discriminate between vegetarian and non-vegetarian entrees where spice level is concerned.

All four main vegetarian entrees were bland and spiceless, reducing me to a sobbing fit of misery.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Veg Entrees Image ©
Mutter Paneer, Bhindi Masala, Dal

Channa Peshawari was a spiceless affront to Indian tastebuds.

Sure the Channa was well cooked and served with medium thick brown color gravy. It seemed like I was eating boiled Chickpeas floating in brown gravy.

Folks, in a long life of eating Bhindi Masala never did such a travesty make contact with my spice hardened Indian palate.

What about Mutter Paneer?

Again, nothing but finely boiled green peas with some fresh Paneer cubes thrown into it.

No spice, no flavor.

Zilch. Nada.

Dosa - Relief

Some relief came in the form of South Indian treats, Mysore Masala Dosa and Onion Masala Dosa.

Dosas were crisp as they should be and came smeared with spicy masala paste.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Dosa Image ©
Mysore Masala & Onion Masala Dosa

While I had no real complaints with the Dosa, the accompanying Coconut Chutney was below par.

Coconut Chutney was low on green chillies and tasted like finely ground Coconut.

To its credit, the Chutney was not cold like at a lot of New Jersey Indian restaurants.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Sambar Image ©

Sambar was medium thick, a little tangy and hot temperature wise. But it was low on Toor Dal, Sambar spices and vegetables. It just included a few pieces of Tomato.

Naan Bread and Plain Rice

Naan bread daubed with butter came piping hot to the table.

I really liked it.

Ditto with plain white rice which packed a freshly cooked texture.

Gajar Halwa

Gajar Halwa looked better than it tasted, reminding me of the saying "All That Glitters is Not Gold".

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Gajar Halwa Image ©
Gajar Halwa

Gajar Halwa with powdered Pistachio and Almond toppings looked pretty.

Alas, it was low on sweetness and sugar and a little dry.

Clean Ambiance

When I walked in around 12PM, there were three diners digging into their Tandoori Chicken.

A waiter greeted me with a smile and quickly showed me to a table.

The restaurant floor was clean. Tables did not have any table cloth or table mats. Silver (Steel spoon and fork) was kept on a paper napkin. But, the drinking water glasses were placed upside down - Not a good hygiene practice.

Salt 'n' Pepper Cherry Hill NJ Tables Image ©

Buffet counter had sumptuous quantity of food.

And vegetarian and non-vegetarian items were placed in separate areas, a good practice.

Water glasses were refilled and used plates removed without prompting.

Salt 'n' Pepper Rating - Disappointing

Given my craving for hot and spicy Indian food, I was crestfallen as I left the restaurant.

For much of the food I sampled at Salt 'n' Pepper, be it vegetarian or non-vegetarian, was low on heat and spices.

Bottom line, Salt 'n' Pepper lacked the magic I expect from Indian food. - ©

Other New Jersey Indian Restaurants

Aabhar Freehold
Anjappar Chettinad
Arusuvai Chettinad
Bangalore Express
Bengali Sweets
Bengali Lunch
Bombay Local Pizza
Bombay Talk
Bombay Wok
Cafe Royal Paan
Calcutta Chinese
Chand Palace
Coriander Bistro
Cross Culture
Curry Crust Pizza
Curry On
Dakshin Express 1
Dakshin Express 2
Deccan Spice
Desi Galaxy
Desi Wok
Divine Curry
Dosa Express
Dosa Grill
Dosa Hut
Dosai Place
Flavor Junction
Flavors of India
Gagan Bistro
Ganesh Dosa House
Gourmet Restaurant
Gourmet Sweets
Guru Palace
Hot Breads
Hot Peppers
Hyd Biryani
Hyderabadi Biryani
Jassi Sweets
Kamat Dosa
Masala Grill
Mirchi Edison
Moghul Express
Myilai Masala
Mysore Woodlands
Nimit Palace
Palace of Asia
Paradise Biryani
Paradise Biryani
Persis Biryani
Punjabi Express II
Punjabi Kitchen
Quality Sweets
Rajbhog Iselin
Rajbhog Cherry Hill
Rajbhog Sweets
Rasoi II
Red Chutney
Saravanaa Bhavan
Shalimar Grill
Shalimar Sweets
Shan & Punjab
Spice Palace
Square Cut
Spice Zone Edison
Sri Biryani House
Sukh Sagar
SV Temple Canteen
Swaminarayan Sweets
Szechuan Garden
Tabaq Edison
Tabaq Sweets
Talk of the Town
Tandoori Bite
Taste of Punjab
Trader Joe's
Trupti Biryani
Udipi Cafe
Urban Spice
Lunch Buffets
Biryani Spots
Heat & Eat Curry
Newark Ave Buffet
Veg Restaurants
24-Hrs Restaurants
NJ Dosa Places
Clash of Biryanis
Samosa Law Suit
Biryani Law Suit